The Story of a High-Maintenance Maintenance Director

About a decade ago, I worked at a hospital. And like every hospital, we produced a monthly newsletter for the local community.

One day, the marketing director had a great idea:
write a profile about the maintenance director.

Everyone said the same thing about the guy:
“He’s incredibly humble.”

Easy story, right?

So the staff copywriter (not me) headed over to the main campus to interview him and a few of his employees.

The maintenance director had one request:

“Don’t make the story too much about me. I want to focus on my team too.”

Fair enough…

The first draft gets written and sent out for approval.

“This is too focused on me. Talk more about my team.”

No problem.

A few edits later:

“Take out this quote about my leadership and replace it with the quote about how great my team is.”

Round 3.
Round 4.
Round 5.

Same story every time.

After about two weeks of revisions, this guy isn’t even the main character in the article anymore.

At one point, I peeked my head over the cubicle divider and said to the copywriter:

“You figure a guy this humble wouldn’t be this big of a pain in the ass, right?”

Over the years, I’ve realized a lot of good men struggle to receive appreciation.

Including me.

We deflect compliments.
We crack a joke.
We downplay accomplishments.
We redirect praise almost as soon as it leaves someone’s lips.

Half the time, I don’t even say “thank you” before I deflect.

And it’s not for show.

It’s not false humility.
I’m not secretly wishing for attention.
And I don’t think most men are either.

Many men have been taught—usually not in some explicit way—that accepting appreciation feels dangerously close to arrogance.

So we minimize ourselves constantly.

And at first, it feels admirable.

But sometimes humility quietly turns into something else:

an inability to simply receive gratitude.

And here’s the strange paradox I’ve started noticing:

Constantly rejecting appreciation can become its own form of self-focus.

Not intentionally.
Not maliciously.

But eventually, everyone around you has to start managing your discomfort instead of simply expressing their gratitude.

Your employees want to celebrate you.
Your wife wants to appreciate you.
Your kids want to admire you.
Your friends want to acknowledge something good in you.

And instead of simply accepting it, you immediately redirect it.
Minimize it.
Deflect it.
Turn it into a joke.
Or insist someone else deserves the credit more.

Again, I don’t think most men do this because they secretly want attention.

I think a lot of us genuinely feel uncomfortable being seen too directly.

But there’s a difference between humility and refusing to let people appreciate you.

At some point, constantly pushing praise away stops being generosity and starts becoming another way of controlling the interaction.

Because now the conversation isn’t about gratitude anymore.

It’s about convincing you that you’re worthy of it.

And sometimes, without even realizing it, we redirect the discomfort onto someone else.

We immediately hand the spotlight to a coworker.
Our spouse.
Our team.
Anybody but us.

Now, to be clear, there’s nothing wrong with sharing credit.
Good leaders should do that.

But there’s a difference between honoring other people and instinctively erasing yourself from the equation because being appreciated feels uncomfortable.

Sometimes humility becomes less about lifting others up and more about moving discomfort somewhere else.

Sometimes we aren’t rejecting praise because we’re humble.

Sometimes we’re just trying to get out of the emotional spotlight as quickly as possible.

The strongest men I know usually aren’t attention seekers.

They’re not the loudest guy in the room.
They’re not constantly trying to prove themselves.
They don’t need every conversation to orbit around them.

But they’ve learned something important:

Accepting appreciation gracefully is very different from demanding it.

You don’t have to shrink yourself to prove you’re humble.

You don’t have to immediately explain why someone else deserves more credit.
You don’t have to make a joke.
You don’t have to swat every compliment like it’s a morally dangerous mosquito.

Sometimes the healthiest response is simply:

“Thank you. That means a lot.”

And then move on.

Because real humility isn’t pretending you’ve done nothing worthwhile.

It’s being able to hold two truths at the same time:

Other people helped me.
And I still contributed something meaningful, too.

I think that’s part of grounded masculinity that doesn’t get talked about much.

A secure man can appreciate other people without erasing himself.
He can lead a team without pretending he had no impact.
He can accept gratitude without turning it into guilt.

And maybe maturity is realizing that letting people appreciate you isn’t arrogance.

Sometimes it’s actually a gift to them too.

Looking back, I think that maintenance director probably missed something important.

Nobody wanted to write about him because he demanded attention.

People wanted to tell his story because of the kind of man he’d quietly become.

Reliable.
Steady.
Respected.
The kind of leader whose employees genuinely wanted him to get some recognition for once.

And honestly, that’s probably the irony underneath the whole thing:

The men most worthy of appreciation are often the ones least comfortable receiving it.

But maybe part of maturity is learning that accepting gratitude doesn’t make you arrogant.

Maybe it’s simply allowing the people around you to express something they genuinely feel.

Without minimizing it.
Without redirecting it.
Without arguing with them about it.

Just:

“Thank you. That means a lot.”

And then letting that be enough.

Until next time—
keep the fires burning.
– Clay

New here? Start with this post → I Write, God Laughs

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links in this newsletter are affiliate links. If you buy something, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only share things I genuinely find valuable.

You don't have to read everything — just the right thing. 1440's daily newsletter distills the day's biggest stories from 100+ sources into one quick, 5-minute read. It's the fastest way to stay sharp, sound informed, and actually understand what's happening in the world. Join 4.5 million readers who start their day the smart way.

Join for free today!